Web3 CMO Stories Podcast with Melanie Borden

If you think about what other people perceive of you all day long, you will go insane.

Introduction

Hello everyone, and welcome to the Web3 CMO Stories podcast.My name is Joeri Billast, and I am your host.

Today, I am excited to be joined by Melanie Borden. Melanie is the founder of The Borden Group, an executive visibility advisory firm that helps leaders translate expertise into measurable growth across modern search. She is a trusted personal brand strategist and GTM advisor, working with executives to align their expertise with digital presence and future-proof their careers.

Melanie is also the author of Theatre of the Mind, a book that explores the internal narratives that shape how leaders show up publicly.

Melanie, welcome to the show.

Visibility Begins Before Strategy

One of the central ideas in Theatre of the Mind is that visibility does not start with strategy, channels, or confidence.

From Melanie’s experience, visibility often begins with a triggering event:

  • A company preparing for an IPO

  • A new product launch

  • Competitive pressure in the market

  • A leadership transition

At that moment, leaders ask themselves:“This is something I need to do. But where do I start?”

The problem is that many leaders jump directly to output without first addressing internal clarity.

Visibility With Credibility vs Performative Visibility

A key distinction Melanie makes is between credible visibility and performative visibility.

Performative visibility often shows up when leaders:

  • Edit their content excessively to please algorithms

  • Change messaging based on engagement instead of intent

  • Chase applause rather than alignment

  • Optimize for vanity metrics instead of long-term outcomes

This behavior often leads to content that looks polished but feels disconnected from real goals, such as trust, authority, and revenue.

As Melanie explains, visibility driven by algorithm appeasement rather than purpose rarely converts into anything meaningful.

Trust Is Lost Before Content Is Published

During the conversation, I shared an insight from my own book, The Future CMO.

Trust is not created by content itself.It is shaped by what leaders do before they speak.

Melanie highlighted several ways leaders unintentionally erode trust early:

  • Speaking on topics they are not deeply versed in

  • Creating presence based on expectations instead of truth

  • Failing to respond to genuine engagement from customers

  • Delegating authentic interaction to assistants

  • Being visibly inconsistent on public platforms like LinkedIn

Because everything is visible today, including comments, reactions, and silence, trust is built or damaged in real time.

Internal Misalignment and Public Leadership

Many founders and CMOs feel pressure to be seen, but not fully understood.

This often happens when:

  • Career growth outpaces personal identity growth

  • Leaders step into visibility roles before internal alignment

  • Visibility feels like performance instead of expression

Closing the gap between who you are and how people experience you creates calm, stability, and authenticity.

When that alignment is missing, visibility becomes exhausting.

Personal Branding Is Leadership in Public

Personal branding is not vanity.It is leadership expressed publicly.

Melanie explains that internal identity always leaks into external signals. When leaders speak from fear, caution, or self-protection, people sense it immediately.

True authority comes from:

  • Speaking on what you genuinely know

  • Leading with clarity rather than approval-seeking

  • Sharing perspective, not positioning

  • Understanding that visibility is about service, not ego

Fear, Over-Preparation, and Silence

One of the biggest blockers Melanie sees is over-preparation.

Examples include:

  • Endless editing and rewriting

  • Routing posts through multiple stakeholders

  • Over-reliance on legal or corporate filters

  • Delaying action until it feels “perfect”

These behaviors are usually rooted in fear:

  • Fear of judgment

  • Fear of upsetting shareholders

  • Fear of saying the wrong thing

  • Fear of being seen before feeling ready

AI, Search, and Human Authority

AI is reshaping search, credibility, and perception.

But the most valuable human quality today is integrity of voice.

AI can help with:

  • Strategy

  • Research

  • Structuring ideas

But AI cannot replicate:

  • Presence

  • Lived experience

  • Perspective shaped by real decisions

AI should amplify human voice, not replace it.

Building a Searchable Presence Without Burnout

Visibility burnout is real, especially for executives.

Melanie recommends shifting away from traditional KPIs and focusing on non-obvious signals, such as:

  • Direct messages and private outreach

  • Long-term silent followers who reach out years later

  • Even negative comments or criticism

Negativity often signals impact. People do not criticize what does not matter.

These signals rarely appear in dashboards but are powerful indicators of resonance.

Organizational Impact of Executive Visibility

When leaders step into visibility with alignment, internal change follows quickly:

  • Teams feel permission to show up

  • Culture becomes more open and psychologically safe

  • Employee retention improves

  • Talent acquisition becomes easier

  • Customers connect with humans, not logos

Visibility creates a ripple effect across the organization, entirely organically.

Why Leaders Rarely Slow Down to Reflect

Many leaders struggle to create space for reflection because visibility was not part of their early career training.

Like physical fitness, visibility is a muscle:

  • It requires practice

  • It requires repetition

  • It requires reframing identity

Reflection unlocks strategy faster than execution ever could.

Writing the Book and Imposter Syndrome

Melanie shared that writing Theatre of the Mind surfaced unexpected imposter syndrome.

Despite experience and success, she questioned:

  • Who will read this?

  • Do I really know enough?

She rewrote the book three times over 18 months.

The final version became stronger because it was infused with lived experience, not theory.

Writing a book is one of the most challenging but transformative leadership exercises.

The One Mindset Shift Leaders Need Now

Melanie’s advice for founders and CMOs navigating AI, Web3, and constant visibility pressure:

Remember your wins.

She keeps physical binders filled with:

  • Emails

  • Comments

  • Awards

  • Milestones

  • Proof of impact

Because if you constantly focus on how others perceive you, you lose yourself.

Self-trust comes from evidence, not opinions.

Where to Find Melanie Borden

All links are available in the show notes and blog article on webdrie.net.

Closing

If you found this episode valuable, share it with a colleague, founder, or marketer.If you enjoy the podcast, please subscribe and leave a review. It helps the show reach a wider audience.

Thank you for listening, and see you in the next episode of Web3 CMO Stories.

If you want, next I can:

  • Create an SEO-optimized H2/H3 outline version

  • Add schema-friendly FAQ blocks

  • Write a GEO-optimized summary for AI Overviews

  • Extract quotable snippets for LinkedIn and newsletter reuse

Just tell me the next step.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading